HELP!

I have been trying very hard to make my home more of a "home" and less of a transition.  All the while trying to stay within a modest budget.  This entails much thought, research and dwelling.  I dwell so much my head hurts.  I think of an idea and I mull it over and over and over and still feel as if I need 1 or 100 opinions.  Sadly enough, I have been turning to Mr. French in times such as this.  Foolishly thinking his opinion would really be helpful.  It's not.  He is sick of me asking and I am sick of him blowing it off.  In order to save my marriage I need to stop asking him...seriously.

Which is why I turn to you!  I have been shocked and delighted by the level of creativity, beauty, and amount of taste I have stumbled onto in the blogging world. I can't believe it has taken me so long to tap my most amazing resource.  

Here is my latest fleating idea.  I want to spiffy up my dark tiny dining room and something like this is what I have come up with (not the tub, the larger than life photo).

Photo take from Style on a Budget by Emily Chalmers, photo by Debi Treloar

I am currently stuck for 2 reasons.  First I am not sure where to go (hopefully online) to create this type of thing.  I don't think I want canvas...I want smoother than that.  However, it has to have a bit of thickness to it because I don't want to frame it.  Maybe about 1/4-1/2 inch thick?

Ok here is the second issue: Which photo?  These are my current candidates (below each photo is a number).  I would be over the moon thrilled if you would leave a comment giving me your choice and/or advice.  

1

2

3

4

5

THANK YOU SO MUCH!  

Oh and the room is a very pale blue...but no windows and quite dark.